If you’re a pizza lover in Williamsburg, don’t miss these five must-try spots. First, Best Pizza is famous for its White Pie with a chewy crust. Second, L’industrie Pizzeria offers super thin, crunchy slices, including a burrata option. Third, Fini Pizza has unique flavors like Long Pepper Shallot. Fourth, Joe’s Pizza serves classic New York-style slices at budget-friendly prices. Finally, Williamsburg Pizza features a thicker crust and a range of toppings. Discover more about each place!
At a Glance
- Best Pizza: Known for its White Pie, this spot offers quality ingredients and a wood-fired, chewy crust, rated 4.3.
- L’industrie Pizzeria: Features super thin, crunchy Neapolitan-style pies with unique toppings like burrata and fig jam, enhancing the pizza experience.
- Fini Pizza: Recently opened, it serves doughy and crispy pizzas with innovative flavors like Long Pepper Shallot, quickly becoming a NYC favorite.
- Joe’s Pizza: A cash-only, budget-friendly establishment specializing in charred New York-style slices, consistently rated 4.4 for quality and flavor.
- Williamsburg Pizza: Offers thicker crust pizzas with diverse toppings and a friendly atmosphere, plus delicious garlic knots as a perfect side.
Best Pizza
When you’re in Williamsburg and craving authentic New York-style pizza, where should you go?
Head to Best Pizza at 33 Havemeyer St. Owned by Frank Pinello, this neighborhood restaurant excels in quality ingredients and traditional methods.
Their simple menu features the White Pie, topped with multiple cheeses and onions, showcasing their commitment to flavor.
Each slice is cooked in a wood-fired oven, giving it a thin, chewy crust that embodies the best of authentic Neapolitan pizza. This cooking method is similar to the high heat of Neapolitan pizza ovens, which contributes to achieving a perfect crust.
With a solid 4.3 rating, it’s no wonder Best Pizza is hailed as one of the best pizza spots in Williamsburg.
Helpful Hints:
- Try the White Pie.
- Enjoy the cozy atmosphere.
- Visit during off-peak hours for quicker service.
L’industrie Pizzeria
L’industrie Pizzeria stands out in Williamsburg, not just for its location at 254 S 2nd St, but also for its unique approach to pizza-making. Known for super thin pizza with a crunchy texture, this pizzeria has carved a niche in the local pizza scene since 2017. Signature offerings like the burrata slice and inventive toppings such as fig jam with bacon attract both locals and visitors. Complement your meal with Italian treats like maritozzo and bombolone for a full experience.
In addition, L’industrie Pizzeria’s style reflects the growing trend of Neapolitan-style pies that have garnered national acclaim.
| Signature Offerings | Description |
|---|---|
| Burrata Slice | Creamy burrata on a crispy base |
| Fig Jam & Bacon Slice | Sweet and savory flavor combination |
| Mushroom Ricotta & Truffle Oil | Rich toppings for sophisticated palates |
Helpful Hints
- Try the burrata slice for a classic flavor.
- Explore creative toppings for a unique taste.
- Don’t miss the Italian treats to enhance your meal.
Fini Pizza
Fini Pizza, located at 305 Bedford Ave in Williamsburg, has quickly become a remarkable destination for pizza lovers since its opening in summer 2022.
Known for its doughy and crispy texture, Fini Pizza emphasizes quality ingredients and an innovative approach to classic pizza.
Fini Pizza showcases a perfect balance of doughy crispness and high-quality ingredients, reimagining classic pizza with innovative flair.
With around six distinct slices, standout options like the Long Pepper Shallot and a white slice topped with fontina, parmesan, and mozzarella exemplify their commitment to impactful flavors.
This pizzeria has rapidly garnered acclaim as one of the best in NYC, making it a must-try destination in the Williamsburg Brooklyn local food scene. Additionally, their crust structure reflects a unique take on traditional pizza styles, offering a delightful balance between the dough and toppings.
Helpful Hints:
- Visit during off-peak hours to avoid long lines.
- Try different slices to fully appreciate the unique flavors.
Joe’s Pizza
Another standout in Williamsburg’s vibrant pizza scene is Joe’s Pizza, located at 216 Bedford Ave.
This cash-only spot specializes in New York-style pizza, offering fresh slices with a perfectly charred crust, making it a budget-friendly option for pizza lovers. Priced between $3 to $4, it’s an excellent choice for anyone looking for quality without breaking the bank.
With a loyal customer base, Joe’s Pizza is popular in the area and serves as a reliable late-night destination. Its impressive 4.4-star rating reflects the consistent quality and flavor, ensuring you won’t be disappointed when you visit. Additionally, Joe’s Pizza fits perfectly within a region known for its diverse pizza scene, which showcases various styles and flavors.
Helpful Hints
- Bring cash.
- Expect lines.
- Try classic toppings.
Williamsburg Pizza
When you’re in Williamsburg and craving pizza, Williamsburg Pizza at 265 Union Ave is worth a visit.
This pizzeria offers thicker crust pizza that provides a unique take on traditional New York slices. You’ll appreciate the crispy crust and a variety of topping options, making it suitable for every palate.
The friendly staff contributes to a welcoming atmosphere, attracting both locals and visitors alike.
Don’t skip the garlic knots, which pair perfectly with their delicious pizza offerings.
Remember, while slices aren’t available, the whole pies are definitely worth sharing.
Enjoy your experience at Williamsburg Pizza! Additionally, you can find must-try pizza spots that emphasize fresh ingredients and unique flavors throughout the area.
Conclusion
In summary, if you’re a pizza lover in Williamsburg, you have plenty of options to explore. From the classic slices at Joe’s Pizza to the artisanal creations at L’industrie Pizzeria, each spot offers something unique. Don’t miss out on these culinary gems; they’re sure to satisfy your cravings. Remember, it’s a pizza paradise, so plunge in and discover your favorites. By trying each pizzeria, you’ll find your perfect slice in no time.
